18/11/2026 | Writer: Kaos GL

At the first hearing in the case seeking prison sentences for four SPoD founders and the dissolution of the association, the court ordered the release of two imprisoned rights defenders and lifted the judicial supervision measures imposed on the other two defendants.

Release ordered in SPoD trial: Two rights defenders regain freedom after 64 days! Kaos GL - News Portal for LGBTI+

The first hearing in the trial of four rights defenders from the Association for Social Policy, Gender Identity and Sexual Orientation Studies (SPoD), as part of the “My Family Is Safe” operations launched on September 12, was held on November 18 at the Istanbul 27th Criminal Court of First Instance in Çağlayan Courthouse.

More than 100 people attended to follow the proceedings, which sought prison sentences for four rights defenders, two of whom were held in pretrial detention, as well as the dissolution of the association.

Only a limited number of journalists, lawyers, defendants' relatives, academics, diplomatic representatives and SPoD representatives were allowed into the courtroom. Those who were not admitted were made to wait in the corridor.

Among those following the hearing were representatives of the Delegation of the European Union to Türkiye and the diplomatic missions of Sweden, the Netherlands, Belgium and the United Kingdom, as well as Kaos GL, ÜniKuir, Pembe Hayat, Lambdaistanbul, 17 Mayıs, HEVİ LGBTI+, Genç LGBTI+, GALADER, LİSTAG, Muamma, BiL+, Trans Pride, Istanbul Pride, Ankara Pride, Hafıza Merkezi, CŞMD, Havle, the Istanbul Branch of the Human Rights Association (İHD), Queer Feminist University Students, the Women for Women's Human Rights Association and TTM.

Representatives of the Workers' Party of Türkiye (TİP) Central Executive Committee and LGBTI+ Bureau, the Socialist Party of Türkiye and its LGBTI+ Commission, the Izmir Contemporary Lawyers Group, Eğitim Sen Branch No. 6, the Socialist Party of the Oppressed (ESP), the DEM Party Kadıköy District Organization, EHP, İDP and the Friedrich Ebert Foundation also followed the hearing.

Imprisoned defendants: “We are detained because we helped establish the association 15 years ago”

The hearing began with the defenses of the imprisoned defendants.

The defendants stated that they were among SPoD's founders but no longer held positions in the association's management. They emphasized that they were now being held in pretrial detention simply because they had participated in establishing the association approximately 15 years ago.

One of the imprisoned defendants stated that the indictment contained no specific accusation against them and that they saw nothing objectionable about participating in an association working in the field of social policy. The defendants' lawyers argued that there was no concrete evidence supporting the charge of violating the Law on Associations and that the case file contained only a police report. Emphasizing that the detention orders were disproportionate, the lawyers stated that the assessment report prepared by law enforcement did not constitute admissible evidence.

The lawyers also pointed out that the indictment failed to explain how the financial transfers cited in the case or the screening of the documentary My Child could constitute criminal offenses. They noted that one defendant had held no position of authority within SPoD since 2015 and drew attention to the eight-year statute of limitations applicable to the alleged offense. The lawyers requested the defendants' acquittal and release.

“Seeking to shut down an association established for rights advocacy will not make our families safe”

Cihan Hüroğlu, one of SPoD's founders who was standing trial without being held in pretrial detention, stated that he had served on the association's Executive Board and that its activities had never gone beyond the objectives and responsibilities set out in its bylaws.

Hüroğlu stated in his defense:

“The association's activities do not constitute a crime in any way. The association continues its work in accordance with its bylaws. Although I have had no involvement with the association since the pandemic, I do not believe that any of the matters cited as grounds for charges in the indictment constitute a crime. I request my acquittal.”

Hüroğlu's lawyer, Bilge Bilgin, stated that the indictment contained no concrete accusation and pointed out that even the association's chairs and published brochures had been cited as grounds for the charges. Bilgin recalled that My Child was a documentary screened in cinemas and distributed with an official certification label. She also argued that the indictment's reference to Article 41 of the Constitution, concerning the protection of the family, had no legal basis in the case.

Criticizing the request to dissolve the association, Bilgin stated:

“SPoD is facing a dissolution request. Seeking to shut down an association established for social policy and rights advocacy will not make our families or our children safe. The violations caused by moving away from the social welfare state, families being condemned to poverty, and children being sent to school hungry cannot be resolved by shutting down an association working in the field of human rights!”

Lawyer Yelda Koçak Urfa requested the lifting of the travel ban imposed on her client. Arguing that the conditions necessary to justify continued judicial supervision no longer existed, Urfa stated:

“If a report was prepared documenting everything down to the association's chairs, there is no need for either pretrial detention or judicial supervision measures.”

“Sexual orientation and gender identity cannot be changed through propaganda, encouragement or promotion!”

Psychologist Özlem Çolak, another SPoD founder standing trial without pretrial detention, stated in her defense that she had not held any administrative position within the association since 2011 and criticized the allegations in the indictment.

Çolak stated:

“After seeing the indictment, I reviewed all the association's activities, both as a founding member facing these accusations and as a psychologist working in the field of trauma, despite having had no administrative involvement with the association since 2011. And what I found was this: All the association's activities are consistent with its founding purpose. There is a huge gap between the indictment and reality. I still do not understand what I am being accused of. There are allegations of propaganda and encouragement targeting children and young people. As a psychologist, I want to state clearly: As recognized by all mental health authorities, sexual orientation and gender identity cannot be changed through propaganda, encouragement or promotion! In fact, there were practices aimed at turning LGBTI+ people heterosexual for many years, and we clearly saw that this was not possible. I have worked for many years in difficult circumstances involving migration and disasters. My area of expertise is trauma. What harms children and young people and causes them trauma is being deprived of their rights.”

Çolak's lawyer, Burcu Uçuran, emphasized that SPoD had undergone numerous inspections since its establishment and criticized the lawsuit filed on grounds of “public morality.”

Arguing that the allegations in the indictment were arbitrary, Uçuran stated:

“The association has undergone numerous inspections since its establishment. A lawsuit is now being filed against an association that is inspected every year, based on a subjective concept such as ‘public morality.’ We are facing arbitrary allegations. No one can be prosecuted on the basis of concepts such as encouragement or propaganda that do not exist as criminal offenses under the Penal Code. The documentary My Child has been cited as grounds for the charges. I would like this court to watch the documentary as well. It is a highly educational and informative documentary about families who love their LGBTI+ children. We recommend it.”

“There is no criminal penalty for being LGBTI+ in Türkiye”

SPoD's lawyer, Furkan Yurt, requested that the association be admitted as a party to the proceedings.

Yurt stated that investigators had examined everything down to the number of chairs in the association's office but had failed to identify any activity constituting a crime.

He stated:

“The prosecutor conducting the investigation claims both that the association engaged in activities contrary to its bylaws and that the bylaws themselves are unconstitutional. However, inspections carried out by inspectors from the Ministry of Interior found no violation of the Constitution. These inspections established that no unlawful activity had taken place.”

Yurt also recalled that jurisdiction over the dissolution of an association lies with a civil court of first instance, rather than a criminal court of first instance.

Emphasizing that being LGBTI+ is not a crime, Yurt stated:

“There is no criminal penalty for being LGBTI+ in the Republic of Türkiye. Two people have been deprived of their liberty for 64 days by disguising something that is not defined as a crime under the Turkish Penal Code as a matter of ‘public morality.’”

Following the defense statements, the court accepted SPoD's request to participate in the proceedings. In the prosecution's opinion, the prosecutor requested that the imprisoned defendants remain in pretrial detention and that the judicial supervision measures imposed on the other defendants continue.

Contrary to the prosecutor's request, the court ordered the release of the two imprisoned defendants and lifted the judicial supervision measures imposed on the two defendants standing trial without detention. No decision was announced regarding the request to dissolve the association. The next hearing is scheduled for February 12, 2027.


Tags: human rights, media, lgbti
Kaos